3D rendering of a large gold and marble gavel striking a pedestal made of stacked blue and white Facebook photo icons, with a digital red alert sign displaying 'META FINE $887M' in front of a futuristic Colosseum building.

Italy fines Meta $887M over Facebook users’ photo access

Italy has fined Meta €805 million, approximately $887 million, after finding that Facebook accessed Android users’ photos, videos and related data without obtaining specific consent or adequately explaining how the information would be used.

The penalty was announced on November 14 by Italy’s Data Protection Authority, which said the company violated privacy rules through a Facebook feature that suggests photos and videos from users’ phone galleries while they browse the platform.

The feature, called “Get suggestions from gallery when browsing Facebook,” allows users to receive suggestions from their personal photo libraries that they can potentially share as posts.

However, investigators found that Facebook requested access to users’ galleries through a general permission covering multiple app functions. This meant users were not clearly informed that granting the permission would also allow the app to access their photos and videos for content suggestions.

The regulator also found that the feature was enabled by default.

Italy orders Meta to change Facebook’s photo access feature

Alongside the €805 million fine, Italy’s data protection authority has given Meta 60 days to disable the feature by default and obtain separate, informed consent from users before accessing their phone galleries for this purpose.

The investigation found that approximately 20 million Android users in Italy could have been affected.The regulator said the size of the penalty reflected the number of people affected, the duration of the alleged privacy violation and Meta’s lack of cooperation during the investigation.

The authority also rejected Meta’s position that the matter should fall under the jurisdiction of Ireland, where the company has its European headquarters.

The investigation began in 2025 and focused on how Facebook accessed photos and videos through its gallery suggestions feature.

Meta plans to appeal the $887 million fine

Meta has strongly disagreed with the regulator’s decision and said it plans to appeal the penalty.

The company argued that users must grant permission through their Android device settings before the feature can access their photos and videos. It also said users can change or withdraw that permission at any time.

Meta described the fine as disproportionate and maintained that the feature was designed to make it easier for people to share photos and videos on Facebook.

The Italian investigation did not examine whether Meta used the accessed photos and videos to train its artificial intelligence models. The company has previously denied using content from the feature for AI training.

The regulator also reserved the right to investigate separately a newer feature introduced in 2026 that allows content from users’ photo galleries to be processed in the cloud.

Another privacy challenge for Meta

The latest penalty adds to Meta’s growing regulatory challenges over how it collects, accesses and uses personal information.

The company has faced several investigations and legal disputes involving user privacy, data protection and its handling of personal information across Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp.

For Android users, the Italian decision highlights the importance of understanding the permissions granted to social media applications, particularly when those permissions involve access to personal photos, videos and other files.

The case also raises a question about how much access technology companies should receive to information stored on users’ devices, and whether general app permissions provide enough transparency when different features require access to the same data.

Meta’s planned appeal means the legal dispute is not necessarily over. However, the decision sends a strong message that regulators expect technology companies to obtain clear and specific consent before accessing sensitive personal information.

Leave a Reply